23 Italian Restaurants in FLORIDA (Tasty, High-End, Classy)
When a pizza or pasta craving hits, where should you go?
While Florida is better known for its seafood, Cuban food, and Latin American cuisine, this diverse state also serves up tasty Italian eats.
Veal, gnocchi, and risotto are just a few of the Italian-style dishes you’ll find on this list of 23 Italian restaurants in Florida.
As you’ll see, many of these eateries offer unique atmospheres for a variety of occasions.
Whether you desire a cozy, low-key space or an upscale, sleek eatery with white tablecloths, you’ll find something to suit your taste.
Read on to discover 23 authentic and popular Italian restaurants!
And by the way, you may also want to check out the best Chinese Restaurants in Florida.
Italian Restaurants in Florida City, Florida
1. La Churrasqueria
The Florida Keys Outlet Marketplace is home to this quaint Italian eatery.
It’s a hidden gem in this outlet, well-known by locals, and often overlooked by tourists or people coming to visit this mall.
All you have to do to order in this low-key dining establishment is enter the food court, go up to the counter, place your meal order, and then take it out with you.
Customers can always count on quality food and friendly service at La Churrasqueria.
Menu items include churrasco sandwiches, hamburgers, hot dogs, churros, and more.
Churros are the favorite among many guests at this Italian establishment.
If the weather’s nice in Florida City, you can even take your meal to the outdoor dining area and enjoy the casual atmosphere.
Address: 935 N Krome Ave, Florida City, FL 33034
2. NikMary Pizza
If you’re craving delightful pizza, stop by NikMary’s in Florida City!
They serve hot and ready pizza every day of the week in a casual, kid-friendly, cozy atmosphere.
Order hot pizza, juicy wings, or flavorful pasta for a casual lunch or an efficient dinner.
Popular for lunch, dinner, or dining alone, there’s no occasion that could pass by this pizza diner.
There’s no better way to quickly order a satisfying meal to feed the whole family than with a large pizza with your choice of toppings, from pepperoni to green veggies and everything in between.
Note that they also have wheelchair-accessible parking, entrance, and seating available to ensure that everyone is welcome and can enter safely.
When you’re in the neighborhood, it’s worth stopping by to indulge in this delicious New York-style pizza.
Address: 250 Palm Dr, Florida City, FL 33034
Also see our article on Pizza in Florida.
Italian Restaurants in Florida Keys, Florida
1. Bayside Gourmet
If you find yourself in the Islamorada of the Florida Keys, craving Italian, stop by Bayside Gourmet for pizza, pasta, and other tasty Italian dishes.
It’s family-owned and operated with specialty menu items that are authentic yet served in a modern cafe setting.
Their gourmet pizzas are handmade, hand-tossed, and served New York style, and they come in 12″ or 16″ sizes to suit any party.
For an extra bit of fun during your visit, try a few of their craft beers and hang out on the outside patio to enjoy the weather and laid-back ambiance.
While it’s not ideal for large groups or gatherings, it’s perfect for an intimate evening out with a friend or partner.
Besides gourmet pizzas, they serve appetizers, soups, Cuban sandwiches, and fish tacos.
Address: 82758 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
2. Alfredo’s Cookhouse
Alfredo’s is a family-style, old-school diner in Key Largo.
They serve homey Italian meals like chicken alfredo, shrimp scampi, and pasta primavera, among other delicious Italian eats.
At Alfredo’s, guests always love the quality of food and service.
They serve hearty breakfasts that include meaty omelets, breakfast burritos, and chilaquiles.
Lobster mac ‘n cheese is a popular choice, especially after a long day of fishing or boating.
The main draw of this place is that it has a menu with something for just about everyone, and it’s a great stop for tourists in the area who want to relax in the presence of friendly people while enjoying happy hour or a decent meal.
Alfredo’s offers a wide selection of desserts to close out your meal, including key lime pie.
Address: 102250 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
3. La Trattoria Oceanside
Looking for an elegant oceanside dining experience in Key West?
Classic Italian dishes and an exceptional martini list make this white-cloth eatery stand out among other Italian restaurants in the Keys.
Their martini list includes drinks like the Cuervo Cosmo, the Raspberry Chocolate Bomb, the Pineapple Pizazz, the Dirty Goose, the Key Lime Pie, the Spring Rose, the Espresso, the Mochatini, the Italian Lemon Drop, and the Green Apple.
And that’s not all.
It makes for a wonderful dining experience for birthdays, anniversaries, or other special occasions.
From the bread to the gnocchi pasta, guests are blown away by the food quality.
The cozy, charming atmosphere is just what you’d expect of a classy Italian establishment.
La Trattoria has been proudly serving quality cuisine since 1983.
Address: 3593 S Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL 33040
4. Duetto Pizza and Gelato
At this low-key, casual pizzeria, grab a cheesy slice and a cup of creamy gelato for dessert.
Thousands of five-star reviews show this cozy Italian eatery has excellent service, delicious food, and great value.
Every day, there’s a regular flow of happy people ordering hot pizza by the slice and cold gelato, but the service is fast and efficient, so don’t expect to wait long.
It’s less than a half mile from the lively Duval Street in central Key West, making it a very convenient location for tourists who want to grab delicious Italian food without straying too far from the nightlife or local historical attractions.
Choose from twenty different specialty pizzas, or custom-order your very own.
This well-known eatery has been featured in Passport Magazine and Culture Trip.
Address: 540 Greene St #1, Key West, FL 33040
Also see our article on Seafood Restaurants in Florida.
Italian Restaurants in Naples, Florida
1. Osteria Tulia
Relax in a stylish, rustic atmosphere as you sip fine wine and dine on classic Italian cuisine at Osteria Tulia.
An Osteria is a small restaurant in Italy, and Osteria Tulia proudly states they were the first Osteria in Florida.
Chef Vincenzo shares flavors and authentic foods from his childhood in Italy at this one-of-a-kind Italian eatery.
With a proud heritage, the cooks at this restaurant serve the freshest ingredients they can find and use recipes that have been handed down or hand-crafted to give customers the most authentic Italian cuisine experience possible.
Their cocktails and bread with olive oil appetizer are especially popular.
On some weekdays, they offer cocktail or wine specials.
If you plan to go on a weekend, make reservations, because they tend to get very crowded!
Address: 466 5th Ave S, Naples, FL 34102
2. Campiello
Looking for an upscale dining experience on some of the best Italian food around?
Campiello delivers exceptional service and delectable Italian dishes in a modern yet rustic atmosphere.
Their Tour di Italia menu introduces new authentic Italian cuisine every month, so patrons always have something refreshing on the menu to look forward to, even if they’re regulars.
Popular menu items include calamari, short ribs, and snapper.
The fish dishes, which are salmon, snapper, and tripletail, are cooked in an authentic Italian fashion that brings out delicious, savory flavors that will make you feel like you’re in Italy.
Wine connoisseurs will admire the full wine list, which guests can order by bottle or glass.
Don’t forget to save room for a sweet limoncello cheesecake or tiramisu for dessert!
Address: 1177 3rd St S, Naples, FL 34102
3. Vergina Restaurant Naples
At Vergina’s, dining on fine Italian cuisine is fun and memorable, to say the least.
Bask in nightly live music at the bar in this vibrant eatery in Florida’s overrated city of Naples.
They’re conveniently located in the heart of Old Naples, in the downtown area.
If you like smoking hookah, they have a comfy lounge that’s sure to impress you.
Enjoy the finest Wagyu beef meatballs, grilled octopus, or mussels as an appetizer before moving on to the main course, which may be anything from lobster ravioli to filet mignon.
Vergina’s is wonderful for a romantic night out with your partner or a wild evening with your friend group!
Stop by during happy hour for the best drink specials, and feast on authentic pizza or house-specialty pasta.
Address: 700 5th Ave S, Naples, FL 34102
Also see our article on Burger in Florida.
Italian Restaurants in Venice, Florida
1. Made in Italy
Lounge on a quaint patio as you munch on a flavorful wood-fired pizza at this Italian eatery.
Guests love the fantastic service, vegan menu options, and martinis.
It’s an old-fashioned yet modern atmosphere with undoubtedly delicious authentic Italian flavors.
They use fresh ingredients and serve homemade pasta and bread.
The chicken parmesan sandwich, Margherita pizza, and Caprese salad are crowd favorites.
Besides handcrafted gourmet pizzas, you can start with a mozzarella pizza base and build your own pizza using their premium toppings.
If you’re going on a weekend, call ahead to reserve a table because this little place gets packed!
Made in Italy has been serving Italian food to locals and tourists in Venice for over five years, and based on its customer reviews, it won’t slow down anytime soon.
Address: 117 W Venice Ave, Venice, FL 34285
2. Cassariano Italian Eatery
At Cassariano Italian Eatery, you can expect excellent food and service in an upscale atmosphere.
When the server puts down your plate, you’ll be pleased with the tasteful presentation of your Italian meal.
If you need a sleek setting to host your next private party, group celebration, or business meeting, consider Cassariano’s Banquet Room.
You’ll have many appetizer and entree choices between the lunch or dinner menu.
Linguini, homemade spaghetti, ricotta, crusted lamp chops, and roasted duck with fig risotto are just a few of the delectable main courses you can order.
They also have a lengthy wine list to pair with your meal.
Many customer reviews discuss the delicious taste of their meals, the prime location of this downtown eatery, and the wonderful service.
Address: 313 W Venice Ave, Venice, FL 34285
3. La Botte Italian Bistro
Guests who visit La Botte rave about the charming, welcoming, and casual atmosphere.
This Italian eatery in Venice, Florida, has daily specials on top of delicious appetizers, entrees, and desserts.
Note that their dinner specials are made fresh every single day to order.
La Botte is a family-owned establishment that serves fresh, homemade, quality Italian meals Tuesday through Saturday.
They based their name on the famous Italian proverb “good wine comes in small barrels,” indicating their love of quality wine.
Lasagna, strozzapreti, gnocchi, and ravioli are all customer favorites.
Whether you’re getting linguini, the fresh catch of the day, or the fresh meat of the day, you’ll most likely be pleased with the meal.
If you’re going on a weekend, make a reservation because the ten tables here fill up fast!
Address: 533A U.S. 41 Bypass N, Venice, FL 34285
Also see our article on Happy Hours in Florida.
Italian Restaurants in Sarasota, Florida
1. Venezia Italian Restaurant
Ready to experience exceptional Italian food near the beach on Lido Key in Sarasota, Florida?
Venezia offers hospitable service, delicious meals, and a welcoming environment.
The menu is full of classic Italian dishes like pasta, pizza, and meaty entrees.
Guests often mention the tasty gnocchi, salmon, alfredo, and paninis in five-star reviews.
The vast choices for pizza may even be overwhelming for customers, but don’t worry; if you have trouble choosing, the kind and hospitable wait staff will be able to help.
Plus, you can enjoy local views while sitting in their outdoor seating area.
Their fresh pizzas are wood oven-baked with handmade dough, making them some of the best.
Dishes that truly make them stand out among Italian restaurants are shrimp scampi, Diavola pizza, and spaghetti with clams.
Address: 373 St Armands Cir, Sarasota, FL 34236
2. Caragiulo’s Italian American
This delightful family-owned Italian eatery serves handmade bread, meatballs, and other classic Italian dishes in a cozy, casual space.
Italian American dining is at its best in this establishment, where guests choose from a variety of types of pasta and meat entrees cooked with the authentic flavors of Italy.
Consistently delicious food and reasonable prices make this restaurant popular in Sarasota.
If you’d rather eat in your own space, you can order your meal to-go or get it delivered.
They have a catering menu available for large events.
Appetizers include a Caprese board, cauliflower mac ‘n cheese, meatballs, and avocado bruschetta.
Dinner pasta includes tortelloni, angel hair, ravioli, and much more!
Choose from a wide variety of pizza and meat entrees, including locally-caught fish plates.
Address: 69 S Palm Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236
Also see our article on Ice Cream Shops in Florida.
Italian Restaurants in Brandon, Florida
1. Allegria Italiana
Chicken parmigiana, baked clam soup, gnocchi, and veal Valdosta are just a few of the popular dishes that make Allegria Italiana a prime choice for the perfect Italian dinner.
This eatery is welcoming and cozy, and guests frequently report wonderful service as they dine in the comfortable ambiance of this Italian restaurant.
In Brandon, it’s a go-to choice for an intimate date night with food that’s sure to satisfy.
Allegria offers catering, take-out, and delivery.
Stuffed or breaded veal, chicken, eggplant dishes, and lobster are all tasty options available to order on the entree list.
They also have samplers available so you can get a taste of a few appetizers.
Make sure you make a reservation if you go on the weekend because this small place fills up quickly.
Address: 518 Oakfield Dr, Brandon, FL 33511
2. Olde Town Pizzeria & Pasta Co.
Whether you love thin-crust or deep-dish pizza, Old Towne has something for you!
This parlor-style Italian pizzeria leaves guests satisfied and coming back for more.
For instance, customers love the Bacon Cheeseburger pizza, which has crumbled seasoned ground beef, smoked bacon, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese.
Their Philly Cheese Steak, BLT, and Chicken Pesto pizzas are also uniquely delicious.
Besides pizza, you can order a strawberry walnut salad, mozzarella sticks, or garlic knots.
Don’t miss their calzones, sandwiches, and pasta dishes!
Its atmosphere is cozy and warm, welcoming guests to stay long after their final course.
Like any good pizzeria, they have a variety of pizzas to suit every palate.
They even have a lunch menu and a kids’ menu, so feel free to bring the whole family in any time.
Address: 115 W Bloomingdale Ave, Brandon, FL 33511
Also see our article on High Tea in Florida.
Italian Restaurants in Destin, Florida
1. Mimmo’s Ristorante Italiano
Destin has no shortage of Italian restaurants, but Mimmo’s stands out from the crowd thanks to its rustic yet elegant, alluring vibe.
Start off your meal with sauteed shrimp, fresh mussels, house-made meatballs, garlic rolls, or calamari.
Their wood-fired bread, topped with rosemary, olive oil, and caramelized onions, is another good appetizer choice.
Types of pasta at this Italian eatery are seemingly endless, ranging from ravioli and spaghetti to manicotti and linguini.
Meats at this fine establishment include veal, lamb, and chicken, which may be breaded or sauteed, depending on the entree.
They also have quite the spread of pizza choices, from a classic Margherita pizza to roasted red pepper pizza.
Besides those items, they have a wide range of salads, calzones, beverages, and desserts to choose from.
Address: 979 US Hwy 98 E, Ste. 5, Destin, FL 32541
2. Pazzo Italiano Destin
Looking for some of the finest food in beautiful Destin, Florida?
Whether you’re here on vacation or a lifelong local, Pazzo Italiano is an excellent choice for a tasty Italian dinner.
This restaurant is charming, modern, and sleek.
The pizzas are handcrafted and then baked in a wood-fired oven to give you the flavors of Italy.
Two restaurant lovers and business partners came up with a menu that features classic Italian dishes, some with a contemporary twist.
Besides wood-fired pizzas, they serve pasta, calzones, salads, and chef specials.
Customers love the alfredo, grouper, pappardelle, and garlic knots.
They also have a delicious drink menu, including martinis like the Passionfruit Martini.
From start to finish, guests who review this place say it’s a wonderful, inviting experience.
Address: 34904 Emerald Coast Pkwy #114, Destin, FL 32541
3. Vinny McGuire’s
Vinny McGuire’s Pizza Pub is a laid-back, welcoming eatery with mouthwatering pizzas and plenty of diverse ales to choose from.
With so many choices of pizza and pasta on their menu, there’s something that everyone in your family or friend group will enjoy!
Relax as you sip ale and munch on pizza in Vinny’s outdoor seating area, which is perfect when the weather is breezy or mild.
Appetizer favorites include spinach and artichoke dip, fried ravioli, and cheesy bread.
You can create your own pizza by selecting from a large list of tasty toppings, and the first three toppings are on the house.
Another popular menu item is McGuire’s Root Beer, which is brewed in-house and has a crisp, fresh flavor that pairs perfectly with the pizza.
Address: 29 Harbor Blvd, Destin, FL 32541
Also see our article on Coffee Shops in Florida.
Italian Restaurants in South Beach, Florida
1. Il Pastaiolo
Why does Il Pastaiolo have several thousand five-star reviews across restaurant review sites?
This lively yet laid-back eatery in South Beach serves some of the freshest and most authentic Italian flavors in the state and never compromises on quality service.
It’s a family-owned and operated establishment that’s perfect for a night out in Miami Beach.
The pasta is homemade and handmade using old Italian traditions that create consistent, high-quality food that make this Italian eatery so special and remarkable.
Owner Mirko Cipriano moved to Miami Beach from Italy and set up this restaurant in 1999, and they’ve made quite the impression since then.
Their menu incorporates popular specials using seasonal ingredients served with welcoming and personable staff.
Call ahead for reservations, especially on the weekend!
Address: 1130 Collins Ave, Miami Beach, FL 33139
2. Limoncello Miami
Limoncello is a gorgeous, romantic Italian eatery with exquisite service and high-quality, fresh food.
The dining experience is always a memorable one, and each dish is carefully crafted to bring forward the best flavors of Italy.
Their menu has everything from pizza to specialty entrees to pasta.
Lobster ravioli and burrata appetizers are crowd favorites at this comfortable restaurant, but there are plenty of other delicious menu items that prior customers comment on.
If you’re not sure what to eat, your server will be happy to recommend the best options, and you won’t be disappointed!
Limoncello has a wine and drink menu that will add even more excitement to your Italian dining experience.
The interior is beautifully decorated, and you can usually find a lively crowd enjoying the tasty food.
Address: 1334 Washington Ave, Miami Beach, FL 33139
Also see our article on Bed and Breakfasts in Florida.
Italian Restaurants in Fort Lauderdale, Florida
1. Louie Bossi’s Ristorante Bar Pizzeria
Dine in an elegant, tasteful atmosphere at this Fort Lauderdale restaurant.
Choose from a wide range of Italian dishes, or come for beer, breakfast, or brunch.
It’s a prime location in the middle of many fashionable shops and boutiques, and it’s a fine destination for a chic Sunday brunch.
Guests love their drink menu, which has bellinis, martinis, negronis, and other Italian classic cocktails.
Of course, they also serve wine and beer.
Their bruschetta and prosciutto selection is impressive, as is their in-depth entree list, which is full of classic Italian dishes as well as those with contemporary spins.
Whether you’re going out with friends and want to share a pizza, or you’re looking for a romantic and memorable dinner date over fine champagne, Louie Bossi’s will serve you well.
Address: 1032 E Las Olas Blvd, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
2. Cafe Vico Restaurant
Looking for a cozy and enchanting Italian restaurant in Fort Lauderdale?
If so, Cafe Vico might suit your taste!
This Northern Italian restaurant has classic dishes, wine, cocktails, outdoor seating, and friendly service.
Cafe Vico has entertainment and a tempting happy hour that its customers love.
Come for a lively, fun experience as you move from appetizers to the main course.
Crowd favorites include lobster ravioli, flounder, and lasagna.
It’s truly a hidden gem within this vibrant city and is proud to be family-owned.
They use fresh, homemade ingredients and focus on quality service and food, which shows in their excellent ratings!
Keep an eye on their calendar because they also host special events, like a five-course wine and movie night, at their welcoming, exciting restaurant.
Address: 1125 N Federal Hwy, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33304
If you liked this article, you may also like to read about the best Wineries, Breweries, and Pumpkin Patches in Florida.
Looking beyond Florida? Check out our article on the best Italian Restaurants in Illinois and New York’s finest Italian Restaurants.